Walking on Eggs
Can you walk across eggs without cracking them?
The phrase “walking on eggshells” is an idiom that is often used to describe a situation in which people must tread lightly around a sensitive topic. Literally walking on eggshells would require exceptional caution, incredible skill, and a sense of self-control that would be nothing short of amazing. Wait just a second . . . what if eggs were really much stronger than most of us imagine? What if nature’s design of the incredible edible egg was so perfect that the shell was strong enough to withstand the weight of your body? It’s time for the Walking on Eggshells challenge!
SICK Science® is a registered trademark of Steve Spangler, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
//Compose the Material Product list items ?>
- A few dozen eggs that are in egg cartons (Large-sized eggs work best)
- Large plastic trash bag
- Bucket of soap and water (and some disinfectant)
- Barefoot friends
For a demonstration that is a good warm-up to the the main event, see “Squeeze an Egg Without Breaking It” below.
Eggs are amazingly strong, despite their reputation for being so fragile. But, are they strong enough to support the weight of your body? If you just want to attempt the feat of standing on eggs, you’ll only need two cartons of eggs (two dozen eggs). If, however, you’re feeling up to the Walking on Eggshells challenge, pick up six or eight cartons of large-sized eggs.
Spread the plastic trash bag (or bags) out on the floor and arrange the egg cartons into two rows on top of them.
Inspect all of the eggs to make sure there are no breaks or fractures in any of the eggshells. Make any replacements that might be necessary.
It’s important to make sure all of the eggs are oriented the same way in the cartons too. One end of the egg is more “pointy” while the other end is more round. Just make sure that all of the eggs are oriented in the same direction. By doing this, your foot will have a more level surface on which to stand.
Remove your shoes and socks. Find a friend to assist you as you step up onto the first carton of eggs. The key is to make your foot as flat as possible in order to distribute your weight evenly across the tops of the eggs. If the ball of your foot is large, you might try positioning it between two rows of eggs instead of resting it on the top of an egg.
When your foot is properly positioned, slowly shift all of your weight onto the egg-leg as you position your other foot on top of the second carton of eggs.
There will be creaking sounds coming from the egg carton, but don’t get nervous. Ask your friends to step away so that your full weight is on the eggs.
If you have more than two cartons of eggs, what are you waiting for? Keep walking!
How Does It Work
Plain and simple, the shape of the egg is the secret! The egg’s unique shape gives it tremendous strength, despite its seeming fragility. Eggs are similar in shape to a three-dimensional arch, one of the strongest architectural forms. The egg is the strongest at the top and the bottom (or at the highest point of the arch). That’s why the egg doesn’t break when you apply pressure evenly to both ends. The curved form of the shell helps to distribute pressure evenly all over the shell rather than concentrating it at any one point. However, eggs do not stand up well to uneven forces, which is why they crack easily on the side of a bowl. This also explains how a hen can sit on an egg and not break it, but a tiny little chick can break through the eggshell. The weight of the hen is evenly distributed over the egg, while the pecking of the chick is an uneven force directed at just one spot on the egg.
If you guessed that the egg carton probably played a role in keeping the eggs from breaking, you’re right. Joseph Coyle is credited as the inventor of the first container made specifically to keep eggs from breaking as they were transported from the local farm to the store. As the story goes, Coyle invented the egg carton in 1911 as a way to solve a dispute between a farmer and a hotel operator who blamed the farmer for delivering broken eggs. Coyle designed a container made out of thick paper with individual divots that supported each egg from the bottom while keeping the eggs separated from one another. As legend has it, the fully loaded egg carton can even be dropped, and if it lands just right, the eggs will survive the fall.
Science Fair Connection
Walking on eggs is pretty cool, but it isn’t a science fair project, yet. You can create a science fair project by identifying a variable, or something that changes, in this experiment. Let’s take a look at some of the variable options that might work:
- Instead of standing on the eggs, place a board or tile on top of a few dozen eggs and test their strength by stacking books one at a time on top of the eggs. Do different arrangements hold more weight than others?
- Try using other objects besides egg cartons to hold the eggs in place (such as upside down soda bottle caps, toilet paper tubes, etc.). How does the container affect the amount of weight that the eggs can support before cracking under the pressure?
That’s just a few idea,s but you aren’t limited to those! Try coming up with different ideas of variables and give them a try. Remember, you can only change one thing at a time. If you are testing different egg arrangements, make sure that the other factors remain the same!
There’s a very high probability that you’ll break a few eggs while attempting to learn this amazing trick. Since raw eggs carry the danger of Salmonella, it’s important that you clean up, wash your hands, and disinfect the area. Even if you don’t break an egg, it’s still a good idea to wash your hands (and feet!) after handling eggs.
Squeeze an egg Without breaking it
- Start by covering your demonstration area with the large plastic trash bag. This
will make the cleanup much easier (if you happen to make a mess, that is).
- Remove any jewelry you might be wearing on your fingers.You’ll need a completely naked hand to attempt this feat.
- Place the raw egg in the palm of your hand. Close your hand so that your fingers are completely wrapped around the egg.
- Squeeze the egg by applying even pressure all around the shell. Get past your fear of breaking the egg and really put the squeeze on it!
- To everyone’s amazement (mostly your own) the egg will not break. If you had been wearing a ring, the uneven pressure of the band against the shell would have most likely resulted in an amusing display of flying egg yolk. Fun to watch but a bummer to clean up.
- Never rest on your initial success! Try changing the way you hold the egg in your hand to see if the orientation of the egg makes any difference when you put the squeeze on it. If you’re really brave, hold the egg in the palm of your left hand and apply pressure to the egg with your right hand. Consider it an unusual way to “egg-press” yourself. Now, where are those towels you meant to set out before you started all of this craziness?
Getting Past the Fear Factor
If you’re a little nervous about the outcome, try sealing the raw egg in a ziplock plastic bag before putting the squeeze on it. Or, hold the egg over the sink if you’re in the super-brave category.